The 5:2 Diet – reviews, principles, and effects
The number of available weight-loss diets can be overwhelming. One of the eating methods gaining popularity among people struggling with excess weight is the 5:2 diet. It attracts attention not only because of its simplicity but also due to the lack of restrictions for most days of the week. This nutritional approach is based on flexible food intake, with periods of calorie restriction, allowing individuals to enjoy their favorite foods without eliminating them. What are the principles of the 5:2 diet? How much weight can you lose on the 5:2 diet? What are the pros and cons of Dr. Mosley's diet? Is it worth trying the 5:2 diet?
Table of contents
Basic principles of the 5:2 diet
The 5:2 diet, also known as Dr. Mosley's diet, is a form of intermittent fasting. The method allows for regular meals for five days a week, without any dietary restrictions. However, for the other two consecutive days, calorie consumption must be significantly reduced.
According to the creators of this eating plan, men can consume up to 600 kcal, while women should limit their intake to 500 kcal on fasting days. As per Dr. Mosley's guidelines, these calories should be spread across two meals with a 12-hour break in between.
The origin of Dr. Mosley's diet
The 5:2 diet was created by British medical journalist Dr. Michael Mosley, who struggled with high blood sugar and cholesterol levels. After receiving his test results, he decided to apply scientific knowledge, which indicated that short-term fasting could lower cholesterol levels and increase insulin sensitivity.
After three months of dietary restrictions, Dr. Mosley's results returned to normal, and the "side effect" of his dietary approach was weight loss — he lost around 8 kg during the short fasting periods.
Through observations made on his own body, Dr. Mosley teamed up with journalist Mimi Spencer, and together they developed an easy and effective diet known as the 5:2 diet. In 2013, their book The Fast Diet was published, quickly becoming a bestseller and promoting the principles of this innovative eating plan.
How the 5:2 diet works
The 5:2 diet is a structured eating model based on short-term calorie restriction aimed at improving health parameters, such as insulin sensitivity, cholesterol metabolism, and weight loss. At the same time, the calorie reduction on fasting days is thought to shrink the stomach walls, which may lead to reduced calorie intake on non-restricted days, promoting weight loss.
Furthermore, Dr. Mosley believes that fasting days, when carefully planned with low-calorie foods focusing on high-protein and low-glycemic index foods, serve as a kind of exercise, encouraging people to make rational food choices.
The pros and cons of the 5:2 diet
The 5:2 diet is a simple and effective nutritional approach that has garnered much attention, mainly because Dr. Mosley’s plan does not impose any dietary restrictions for the majority of the week. The freedom to eat anything for five days makes the two fasting days easier to manage, which, from a psychological perspective, benefits the body.
The 5:2 diet not only helps with weight loss but can also improve health parameters, positively affecting cholesterol, insulin levels, and blood pressure. Given its flexibility, it is unlikely to cause nutrient deficiencies. It also supports the body’s natural detoxification and regeneration processes, while encouraging people to make healthier food choices.
However, the flexibility in the 5:2 diet can also be a disadvantage. If someone consumes highly processed foods, fast food, ready-made meals, and sweets for the five non-fasting days, they may end up reinforcing poor eating habits.
Some nutritionists and scientists question the short-term fasting approach — while Dr. Mosley believes humans are evolutionarily adapted to short periods of hunger, some experts argue that such practices may lead to fat storage, creating the opposite effect of what is intended.
Potential risks of Dr. Mosley's 5:2 diet
While the 5:2 diet seems promising, there is still a lack of detailed scientific studies confirming its positive effects on human health, including its impact on lipid profiles or carbohydrate metabolism. Moreover, the calorie restriction on fasting days could lead to sharp drops in blood sugar levels, which may be especially dangerous for people with diabetes.
Therefore, it's important to understand that the 5:2 diet may not be suitable for everyone. People with diabetes, pregnant women, those who are underweight, or those with chronic illnesses should avoid this eating plan. It is also not recommended for individuals with eating disorders, as dietary restrictions could worsen unhealthy behaviors and habits.
Adhering to intermittent fasting principles, like those in the 5:2 plan, may also cause unwanted side effects, such as irritability, headaches, dizziness, or feelings of fatigue and weakness.
Results of the 5:2 diet
People who choose to follow the 5:2 diet and make healthy food choices during their five "normal" eating days often experience weight loss, improved well-being, and better parameters such as lipid profiles and carbohydrate metabolism.
However, it's important to remember that excessive calorie restriction during the five "normal" eating days, followed by two days of fasting, can negatively affect the body. This could result in rapid weight loss, which may lead to malnutrition and deficiencies of essential nutrients. On the other hand, consuming too much high-calorie food during non-fasting days may contribute to weight gain and increased body fat.
Long-term use of the 5:2 diet may also lead to the unwanted accumulation of fat, contrary to the intended goal, which could result in the opposite effect.
Sample meal plan for the 5:2 diet
A well-balanced 5:2 diet can be a safe approach to eating. However, poorly planned meals during fasting periods may have negative effects on the body's functioning, disrupting the work of various systems and organs. Here’s an example of a meal plan on Dr. Mosley's diet:
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Day 6
Day 7
Conclusion - is Dr. Mosley’s diet worth trying?
The 5:2 diet is a simple and effective way of eating that, while flexible, requires self-discipline and a basic understanding of nutrition to ensure meals are properly balanced during fasting periods.
When properly followed, the 5:2 diet can lead to desired results, such as weight loss and improved health. However, short-term fasting periods remain controversial among dietitians and researchers, which makes a well-balanced, healthy, and sustainable diet with a negative energy balance a much safer option for those looking to lose weight without the risk of excess fat accumulation.
Bibliography: